Tuesday, March 9, 2010
Sexism?
When reading a social studies book or any book for that matter, have you ever looked for sexism while reading? I think a lot of readers would be surprised in what they find, I know I was. The book I reviewed was Idaho Social Studies, which is used in most 4th/5th grade classes. Looking through the index, I found that referenced men versus women was approximately 70 to 13. The majority of the 13 women referenced gave a sentence or two that gave brief explanations and information. An example was talking about Native American women and their roles, the book quickly summarized women gathering nuts, roots, and cleaned animals while men were out hunting and exploring. At first I was surprised at the substantial difference of material covered between men and women, but then I realized the times in which the majority of the events took place. Way back when, men and women had very specific roles and there wasn't a whole lot of overlap. I think this a common format in most textbooks that talk about history. Men explored, hunted, and fought in wars and battles, and women were gatherers, care takers of the children, cleaners, cookers, and took care of the homes. So although sexism can be found in many books including school textbooks, it is important to keep in mind the times in which they are referring to. It is also important as teachers to maintain a more equal balance of men vs. women in the curriculum, if not, what message is being sent to students. Some great activities for the class can be to have students pick a famous woman or group of women and talk about who they were, what they did, and their significance. Students can present their findings to the class and allow the rest of the class to learn and broaden their perspectives of gender roles.
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Lies
Where to begin with "Lies My Teacher Told Me?" I am learning a lot by reading this, I think. There is a lot to think about with history and how it has been portrayed/taught. There has been a lot of confusion in history and social studies classes about what to teach, how to teach it, and why it should be taught. I am wondering who gets to decide what and when things will be taught. I understand this book is clearing up some messes that textbooks have left and it describes in detail the very important things that are missed and "mis-interpreted." But there still is the problem of teachers only having a pre-determined amount of time to teach a lesson and they must move on. Is there enough time to go into as much detail as necessary so students aren't mislead? Everything can't be covered either, so parts will have to be left out, which parts should be left out? Considering all that, I do strongly agree that students need to hear the truth about history, such everything about Columbus.....at a gradual rate, or with parent permission. That's a tricky one because most parents wouldn't want their 2nd grader to hear about rape, murder, and slavery. So at what point does the "heroification" of "important" people in "our" nations past stop, and all of the info. is presented? This is a tangled knot that has been going on for a long time. It seems to be "easier" to revert back to telling the same stories, telling them the same way, and memorizing the same "facts," probably because the "truth" is inconvenient. The textbooks are getting bigger, the information is as exciting as ever, and it's a wonder why students are "bored" with history and social studies. I think it is important to teach key concepts about material, people/dates/times/ are just as important, but if students can make connections with ideas and concepts about history they might understand it better. Making connections with today's world might help understand "our" history.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
